To purchase a gift card for a friend or family, please see our link at Square Square Gift Card
Choose Your Event Date:
Date selection ensures availability for pickup or delivery. Pickup or delivery options are selectable at checkout. Date availability is shown on the calendar.
Aunt Connie’s Sugar Cream Pie is a velvety, old‑fashioned Indiana classic with a buttery crust and a sweet, creamy filling that tastes like pure small‑town magic.
Our classic dessert tray is a sweet crowd‑pleaser featuring our in‑house favorites — cookies, cupcakes, brownie bites, and seasonal treats. Beautifully arranged and fully customizable to match any event.
Sizing and Qty:
Small feeds 10-15, Medium feeds 20-30, Large feeds 40-50+
Freshly baked in‑house with a mix of 48 favorites — chocolate chip, snickerdoodle, sugar, and strawberry thumbprint cookies. Perfect for sharing or gifting.
Soft, scratch‑made mini-cupcakes — rich chocolate and classic vanilla — topped with smooth, creamy buttercream icing for an elegant finish. Tell us your event colors and we can customize them to match your theme.
